WIND SOLVES ITS BAT PROBLEM

Study Finds Reduction in Turbine Bat Kills
Leora Broydo Vestel, May 18, 2009 (NY Times)

"Wind turbines kill large numbers of bats each year — a public relations quandary for wind energy companies. But the results of a new study show that sacrificing some nocturnal spin time can save the lives of bats…

"The study was conducted by researchers from the Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative at the 34.5 megawatt Casselman Wind Power Project in Pennsylvania. The researchers found that turning turbines off at night during low-wind periods when bats are most active reduced mortality rates – by about 70 percent on average…Twenty-one dead bats were found when turbines were fully operational, while 11 were found when turbines were turned off during low-wind phases."

click thru to watch videos

"The bat-saving measure came with a cost…[S]witching the turbines off when they could otherwise have been generating power would result in an annual loss in productivity of as much as 1 percent…[Or] as much as 1,000 megawatt hours a year…[At] $70.00 to $90.00 a megawatt hour of wind energy, that’s a potential $70,000 to $90,000 annual hit to the bottom line…[S]uch fiscal sacrifices may be necessary to get projects through contentious permitting processes, and also to prevent negating the environmental benefits of renewable power…

"…[B]at kills are increasing as wind farms proliferate…And while turbines are also the cause of many bird deaths, the situation for bats appears to be graver. In studies that tallied bat mortality figures at wind projects across the United States, the number of birds killed per turbine each year ranged from 0.6 to 7.7…The number of bats killed per turbine ranged from 3.4 to 47.5."

click thru to watch videos

"Sometimes the bats die from colliding with the rotor blades – the tips of which can reach speeds of 180 miles an hour – or the turbines can also cause catastrophic damage to a bat’s respiratory system. The sudden drop in air pressure in the area near the blades can cause the bats’ lungs to fill with fluid – similar to when divers surface too quickly and get the bends…[B]ats may be drawn to the shine of the metal on the turbines or the sounds they make. Infrared video shot by researchers sheds light on this fatal attraction…

"B.C.I., industry and government agencies have joined forces to fund ongoing studies. Other solutions under investigation include bat deterrent devices like “sonar jamming” ultrasonic emitters mounted on wind turbine towers."